James Madison Kline - Revision history

Liz: 1880 census Eliz Twp, Lawrence Co, OH James Cline, wife Jemima, 2 girls

2015-07-11T17:11:31Z

1880 census Eliz Twp, Lawrence Co, OH James Cline, wife Jemima, 2 girls

Liz: Ohio death records 1912, James Kline, Ironton, Lawrence Co. OH

2015-07-11T16:41:09Z

Ohio death records 1912, James Kline, Ironton, Lawrence Co. OH

Liz: remove undertainty re. obit; children are correct. & transcriptional date error

2015-07-11T14:56:21Z

remove undertainty re. obit; children are correct. & transcriptional date error

Liz: /* Children */ transcriptional error

2015-07-11T14:54:20Z

‎Children: transcriptional error

Liz: 1900 census Lawrence Co OH, Elizabeth Twp, James Kline, Eliza, dau.Dora E. Kline b. 1876

2015-07-11T06:05:34Z

1900 census Lawrence Co OH, Elizabeth Twp, James Kline, Eliza, dau.Dora E. Kline b. 1876

Liz: 2007 gravestone photo for Dora Kline; & source note. Delete 2 source notes, dissproven speculation re. Dora Kline

2015-07-11T05:25:04Z

2007 gravestone photo for Dora Kline; & source note. Delete 2 source notes, dissproven speculation re. Dora Kline

Liz: 2007 gravestone photo for Dora Kline; & source note.

2015-07-11T04:55:53Z

2007 gravestone photo for Dora Kline; & source note.

Liz: obit of Dora M. Lynch, which dissproves that Dora Kline Lynch was dau. of James Madison Kline, but not the possibility that James M. Kline had a dau. Dora.

2013-09-01T14:13:20Z

obit of Dora M. Lynch, which dissproves that Dora Kline Lynch was dau. of James Madison Kline, but not the possibility that James M. Kline had a dau. Dora.

Liz: obit or Catherine Lynch Graham, dau. of Dora Kline & Hugh F. Lynch; obit placed in Conjecture section. Note added to childrens chart for Nora Kline

2013-08-05T13:58:46Z

obit or Catherine Lynch Graham, dau. of Dora Kline & Hugh F. Lynch; obit placed in Conjecture section. Note added to childrens chart for Nora Kline

Liz: note on blacksmith occupation "as was his father"

2012-12-31T17:55:25Z

note on blacksmith occupation "as was his father"

@@ Line 96: / Line 96: @@
 | '''[[Source:_1850_United_States_Federal_Census|1850 United States Federal Census]]''', PA Clarion Co., Beaver Twp., pg. 539-270, ln. 6-17.  Date of census: 25 Sept. 1850.<br>Jacob Kline, 46, Blacksmith; Susannah, 40, can't read/write; Harriet, F, 20; Franklin, 19; David, 16; Sarah, 15; Charles, 12; ''James'', 11; Susannah, 9; Jackson, 6; Washington, 2; Wesly, 2 mos.  All born PA.
 |[[Image:1850 census pa clarion beaver pg 539-270.jpg|50px|center]]
 |-
 !'''6'''

@@ Line 25: / Line 25: @@
 | '''Military'''    || 1862- 3 yrs  || Co. H, 103 Reg. Pa Vols.  ||Civil War|| <sup class="reference">[8][10][11] </sup>
 |-
-| '''Death'''    ||Mar. 1912   ||Hanging Rock, Elizabeth Twp., Lawrence Co. OH   || || <sup class="reference">[8] [9]</sup>
+| '''Death'''    ||Mar. 1912<br>or 15 Jan 1912  ||Hanging Rock, Elizabeth Twp., Lawrence Co. OH   <br> or Ironton (location of dau. Mary), Lawrence Co. OH|| || <sup class="reference">[8]/[9] or [14]</sup>
 |-
 | '''Burial''' || ||    || || <sup class="reference"> </sup>
@@ Line 124: / Line 124: @@
 !'''13'''
 |'''Research of Hazel Sheffer Crawford''' of Emlenton PA. In Hazel's collection of photographs is one of two children, labeled on back "May and Leona Klein". Forwarded by her nephew Rick Sheffer, Dec. 2012.
 |}
 =Source Notes=
 *Per research of Kerry Kline:  James Madison Kline's 1st wife, Lucinda Rupert, divorced him after he left her in 1866; no children. <br>His 2nd wife, Jemina Null, is presumed to be the daughter of Andrew Null & Julia unknown. James Madison Kline & Jemina Null had 2 daughters (Mary Kline b. ~1868, in OH, & Lenora Kline, b. ~ 1872 in OH.) <br>3rd wife Eliza Hunley was "colored", according to one sworn statement in James' pension file. They may have had a daughter while he was still married to Jemina Null; (possibly Dora Kline b. Jan 1896 in OH)  His Civil War service ended in early discharge due to temporary blindness; filed invalid pension 9June 1887, application # C12469, certificate #440936.   Eliza applied for widow's pension 12 June 1912, application #988230, certificate #884479.<br> After James Kline's discharge from the army, from the Mt. Pleasant Hospital in Wash. D. C., he returned to Church, Clarion Co., PA, where he remained until the middle or latter part of April 1863.  In April 1863 he moved to Vesuvins, Lawrence Co., OH,  where he died in 1912.

@@ Line 98: / Line 98: @@
 |-
 !'''6'''
-| '''1900 U S Federal Census''', OH, Lawrence Co., Elizabeth Twp. enumeration Dist. 65, p. 12 "(Part of) All East of Iron Railroad". Date of census 13 Jun3 1900.<br>Lines 91-93: James Kline, white male, born Mar. 1839, age 61, married 4 yrs, he & parents born PA. Day laborer, 9 mos. not employed, does not read or write, rents a house.<br>Eliza, wife, white female, born July 1871, age 28, married 4 yrs, 1 child born, 1 living in 1900. She & both parents born in OH.  Can read & write.<br>Dora E., daughter, white female, born Jan. 1876, age 4, she & mother born OH, father born PA.
+| '''1900 U S Federal Census''', OH, Lawrence Co., Elizabeth Twp. enumeration Dist. 65, p. 12 "(Part of) All East of Iron Railroad". Date of census 13 Jun3 1900.<br>Lines 91-93: James Kline, white male, born Mar. 1839, age 61, married 4 yrs, he & parents born PA. Day laborer, 9 mos. not employed, does not read or write, rents a house.<br>Eliza, wife, white female, born July 1871, age 28, married 4 yrs, 1 child born, 1 living in 1900. She & both parents born in OH.  Can read & write.<br>Dora E., daughter, white female, born Jan. 1896, age 4, she & mother born OH, father born PA.
 |[[File:1900 Census OH, Lawrence, Elizabeth Twp, Enum Dist 65 p 12.jpg|50px]]
@@ Line 128: / Line 128: @@
 =Source Notes=
 *Per research of Kerry Kline:  James Madison Kline's 1st wife, Lucinda Rupert, divorced him after he left her in 1866; no children. <br>His 2nd wife, Jemina Null, is presumed to be the daughter of Andrew Null & Julia unknown. James Madison Kline & Jemina Null had 2 daughters (Mary Kline b. ~1868, in OH, & Lenora Kline, b. ~ 1872 in OH.) <br>3rd wife Eliza Hunley was "colored", according to one sworn statement in James' pension file. They may have had a daughter while he was still married to Jemina Null; (possibly Dora Kline b. Jan 1896 in OH)  His Civil War service ended in early discharge due to temporary blindness; filed invalid pension 9June 1887, application # C12469, certificate #440936.   Eliza applied for widow's pension 12 June 1912, application #988230, certificate #884479.<br> After James Kline's discharge from the army, from the Mt. Pleasant Hospital in Wash. D. C., he returned to Church, Clarion Co., PA, where he remained until the middle or latter part of April 1863.  In April 1863 he moved to Vesuvins, Lawrence Co., OH,  where he died in 1912.

@@ Line 63: / Line 63: @@
 ! Name || Gender || Date of Birth || Birthplace || Spouse || Notes || Sources
 |-
-| Dora  Kline   ||F ||Jan 1876 ||OH ||   || || <sup class="reference">[6][8][9][12]</sup>
+| Dora  Kline   ||F ||Jan 1896 ||OH ||   || || <sup class="reference">[6][8][9][12]</sup>

@@ Line 63: / Line 63: @@
 ! Name || Gender || Date of Birth || Birthplace || Spouse || Notes || Sources
 |-
-| Dora  Kline (possibly)    ||F ||Jan 1896 (possibly)   ||OH (possibly ||   ||See Research Notes below || <sup class="reference">[8][9][12][14]</sup>
+| Dora  Kline   ||F ||Jan 1876 ||OH ||   || || <sup class="reference">[6][8][9][12]</sup>
@@ Line 81: / Line 81: @@
 |}
 = Photo Gallery =
-[[File:Klein - May & Leona Klein from R Sheffer.jpg|100px|left|thumb|"May & Leona Klein"]][[File:VAL 02 Dora Kline.jpg|100px|center|thumb|Dora Kline 1863-1928, Valley Cemetery, Venango Co. PA]]
+[[File:Klein - May & Leona Klein from R Sheffer.jpg|100px|left|thumb|"May & Leona Klein"]]
 <br style="clear: left"/>
@@ Line 96: / Line 96: @@
 | '''[[Source:_1850_United_States_Federal_Census|1850 United States Federal Census]]''', PA Clarion Co., Beaver Twp., pg. 539-270, ln. 6-17.  Date of census: 25 Sept. 1850.<br>Jacob Kline, 46, Blacksmith; Susannah, 40, can't read/write; Harriet, F, 20; Franklin, 19; David, 16; Sarah, 15; Charles, 12; ''James'', 11; Susannah, 9; Jackson, 6; Washington, 2; Wesly, 2 mos.  All born PA.
 |[[Image:1850 census pa clarion beaver pg 539-270.jpg|50px|center]]
 |-
 !'''8'''
@@ Line 123: / Line 128: @@
 =Source Notes=
 *Per research of Kerry Kline:  James Madison Kline's 1st wife, Lucinda Rupert, divorced him after he left her in 1866; no children. <br>His 2nd wife, Jemina Null, is presumed to be the daughter of Andrew Null & Julia unknown. James Madison Kline & Jemina Null had 2 daughters (Mary Kline b. ~1868, in OH, & Lenora Kline, b. ~ 1872 in OH.) <br>3rd wife Eliza Hunley was "colored", according to one sworn statement in James' pension file. They may have had a daughter while he was still married to Jemina Null; (possibly Dora Kline b. Jan 1896 in OH)  His Civil War service ended in early discharge due to temporary blindness; filed invalid pension 9June 1887, application # C12469, certificate #440936.   Eliza applied for widow's pension 12 June 1912, application #988230, certificate #884479.<br> After James Kline's discharge from the army, from the Mt. Pleasant Hospital in Wash. D. C., he returned to Church, Clarion Co., PA, where he remained until the middle or latter part of April 1863.  In April 1863 he moved to Vesuvins, Lawrence Co., OH,  where he died in 1912.
-* Gravestone for Dora Kline 1863-1928 is at Valley Cemetery, Venango Co. PA, along with those of her uncles, [[Jacob Kline]] & [[Reuben Kline]], & Reuben's son [[John Milton Kline]]. It is possible that  Dora, daughter of James Madison Kline, may have been  returned home to PA from Ohio for burial, or that she returned there to live for a time.  The alternative would be that this stone is for another Dora Kline unfamiliar to us.
 * The obituary of James S. Kline names a daughter Nora Kline, at home (i.e. unmarried).  Whether this is a misprinting of James M. Kline's name, and indicates he did have a daughter Nora, or that there was another Dora Kline but still not the daughter of James M. Kline, is not yet solved.

@@ Line 63: / Line 63: @@
 ! Name || Gender || Date of Birth || Birthplace || Spouse || Notes || Sources
 |-
-| Dora  Kline    ||F ||Jan 1896   ||OH  ||   ||See Source Notes below; connection not clearly established. See also Conjecture section below. || <sup class="reference">[8][9][12]</sup>
+| Dora  Kline (possibly)    ||F ||Jan 1896 (possibly)   ||OH (possibly ||   ||See Research Notes below || <sup class="reference">[8][9][12][14]</sup>
@@ Line 121: / Line 121: @@
 |}
-===Source notes===
+=Source Notes=
-* Per research of Kerry Kline: James Madison Kline's 1st wife, Lucinda Rupert, divorced him after he left her in 1866; no children. <br>His 2nd wife, Jemina Null, is presumed to be the daughter of Andrew Null & Julia unknown. James Madison Kline & Jemina Null had 2 daughters (Mary Kline b. ~1868, in OH, & Lenora Kline, b. ~ 1872 in OH.) <br>3rd wife Eliza Hunley was "colored", according to one sworn statement in James' pension file. They may have had a daughter while he was still married to Jemina Null; (possibly Dora Kline b. Jan 1896 in OH)  His Civil War service ended in early discharge due to temporary blindness; filed invalid pension 9June 1887, application # C12469, certificate #440936.   Eliza applied for widow's pension 12 June 1912, application #988230, certificate #884479.<br> After James Kline's discharge from the army, from the Mt. Pleasant Hospital in Wash. D. C., he returned to Church, Clarion Co., PA, where he remained until the middle or latter part of April 1863.  In April 1863 he moved to Vesuvins, Lawrence Co., OH,  where he died in 1912.
+*Per research of Kerry Kline:  James Madison Kline's 1st wife, Lucinda Rupert, divorced him after he left her in 1866; no children. <br>His 2nd wife, Jemina Null, is presumed to be the daughter of Andrew Null & Julia unknown. James Madison Kline & Jemina Null had 2 daughters (Mary Kline b. ~1868, in OH, & Lenora Kline, b. ~ 1872 in OH.) <br>3rd wife Eliza Hunley was "colored", according to one sworn statement in James' pension file. They may have had a daughter while he was still married to Jemina Null; (possibly Dora Kline b. Jan 1896 in OH)  His Civil War service ended in early discharge due to temporary blindness; filed invalid pension 9June 1887, application # C12469, certificate #440936.   Eliza applied for widow's pension 12 June 1912, application #988230, certificate #884479.<br> After James Kline's discharge from the army, from the Mt. Pleasant Hospital in Wash. D. C., he returned to Church, Clarion Co., PA, where he remained until the middle or latter part of April 1863.  In April 1863 he moved to Vesuvins, Lawrence Co., OH,  where he died in 1912.
+=Research Notes=
-=Conjecture=
+* '''Connection unconfirmed''': Obituary of Catherine Lynch Graham, daughter of Dora Kline Lynch; published by McLean Publ. Co.  Tri County Sunday, Brookville PA, 4 Aug 2013.<br>''Catherine “Kay” Frances Graham'', 95, of Brookville, died Friday, Aug. 2, 2013, at McKinley Health Center. Born Sept. 1, 1918, in Brookville, she was one of six daughters of ''Hugh F. Lynch and Dora (Kline) Lynch''. Kay was the last surviving daughter.   On Jan. 17, 1941, she was ''married to Jacob Clair Graham Jr.'' He preceded her in death in August of 1992. Kay was a beautician who owned and operated Kay’s Beauty Shop for over 40 years.  She is survived by three daughters: Janice L. Lavely and husband Dr. Donald Lavely of Clarion, Barbara Mackins of Brookville and Kathleen Songer and husband Denny of Greensboro, N.C.; eight grandchildren: Dr. Dawn Martin, DVM, Dr. David Lavely and wife Tessie, James A. Lavely and wife Jacquie, Jay A. Lavely, Shane Mackins and wife Kelly, Mindy Mackins-Morton and husband John, Todd Henry and wife Tracey, and Shawna Wilson; 15 great-grandchildren; and special friends, Pat Fenton of State College and Carol Hoak of Brookville.<br>She was preceded in death by her parents; husband; infant son, John Robert Graham; five sisters: Mary Dillon, Marguerite Lynch, Josephine Lynch, Gertrude Lynch and Elizabeth Swartz; and son in law, Joseph Mackins..." Arrangements by Brenda D. Shumaker Funeral Home, Inc., Brookville.  Funeral mass Monday, Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic Church, the Rev. Fr. William Laska. Burial  at St. Mary’s Roman Catholic Cemetery, Brookville.  Memorials to Laurelbrooke Assisted Living, Brookville,PA.  (McLean Publishing Co. - Tri County Sunday - Aug. 4, 2013)<br> This obituary, transcribed by Thelma Kifer, was posted on Keystone Corner site of MyFamily.com
-* Connection unconfirmed: Obituary of Catherine Lynch Graham, daughter of Dora Kline Lynch; published by McLean Publ. Co.  Tri County Sunday, Brookville PA, 4 Aug 2013.<br>"Catherine “Kay” Frances Graham, 95, of Brookville, died Friday, Aug. 2, 2013, at McKinley Health Center. Born Sept. 1, 1918, in Brookville, she was one of six daughters of Hugh F. Lynch and Dora (Kline) Lynch. Kay was the last surviving daughter.   On Jan. 17, 1941, she was married to Jacob Clair Graham Jr. He preceded her in death in August of 1992. Kay was a beautician who owned and operated Kay’s Beauty Shop for over 40 years.  She is survived by three daughters: Janice L. Lavely and husband Dr. Donald Lavely of Clarion, Barbara Mackins of Brookville and Kathleen Songer and husband Denny of Greensboro, N.C.; eight grandchildren: Dr. Dawn Martin, DVM, Dr. David Lavely and wife Tessie, James A. Lavely and wife Jacquie, Jay A. Lavely, Shane Mackins and wife Kelly, Mindy Mackins-Morton and husband John, Todd Henry and wife Tracey, and Shawna Wilson; 15 great-grandchildren; and special friends, Pat Fenton of State College and Carol Hoak of Brookville.<br>She was preceded in death by her parents; husband; infant son, John Robert Graham; five sisters: Mary Dillon, Marguerite Lynch, Josephine Lynch, Gertrude Lynch and Elizabeth Swartz; and son in law, Joseph Mackins..." Arrangements by Brenda D. Shumaker Funeral Home, Inc., Brookville.  Funeral mass Monday, Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic Church, the Rev. Fr. William Laska. Burial  at St. Mary’s Roman Catholic Cemetery, Brookville.  Memorials to Laurelbrooke Assisted Living, Brookville,PA.  (McLean Publishing Co. - Tri County Sunday - Aug. 4, 2013)<br> This obituary, transcribed by Thelma Kifer, was posted on Keystone Corner site of MyFamily.com
+* '''Connection diss-proven''' by the following obituary:  <br>''Mrs. Dora M. Lynch''  A requiem mass was sung on Tuesday morning, October 6, 1953,in the Immaculate Conception church in Brookville, for Mrs.Dora M. Lynch. Rev. Frank A. Hartleb officiated at the services at 9:00 a.m., after which interment followed in thenew Catholic cemetery. Death occurred Saturday, October 3, at 11:15 a.m., for Mrs.Lynch at her residence at 83 Western Avenue, where she hadresided for the past 38 years. The deceased was a native of Brookville, having been bornhere March 19, 1883, a ''daughter of John and Elizabeth(Gooder) Kline''.She was ''married to Hugh F. Lynch'', of Patton, on September 7,1907. Her husband preceded her in death. They leave the following children, all of Brookville: Mrs. Mary Dillon, Josephine and Gertrude Lynch, Mrs. Catherine Graham, and Mrs. Elizabeth Swartz.In addition to seven grandchildren, the following brothers and sisters survive Mrs. Lynch: Lawrence A. Kline, Bernard J. Kline, and May C. Kline, all of Brookville; Rosalia E.Kline, of Washington, D.C., and Frances G. Kline, of Falls Church, Va.<br>(Jefferson Democrat, October 8, 1953; posted online at PA Roots, http://www.pa-roots.org/data/read.php?13,2861)
-=Research Wishlist=
+* The obituary of James S. Kline names a daughter Nora Kline, at home (i.e. unmarried).  Whether this is a misprinting of James M. Kline's name, and indicates he did have a daughter Nora, or that there was another Dora Kline but still not the daughter of James M. Kline, is not yet solved.

@@ Line 21: / Line 21: @@
 | '''3rd Marriage''' || 9 Mar 1897  ||expect OH  ||Eliza Hunley  || <sup class="reference">[8][9][12] </sup>
 |-
-| '''Occupation'''    ||   ||   ||Blacksmith || <sup class="reference">[8] </sup>
+| '''Occupation'''    ||   ||   ||Blacksmith (as was his father) || <sup class="reference">[8] </sup>
 |-
 | '''Military'''    || 1862- 3 yrs  || Co. H, 103 Reg. Pa Vols.  ||Civil War|| <sup class="reference">[8][10][11] </sup>